I started reading The Story of Mankind. It seems like he goes very fast through all the subjects (which I assume you would have to do if you were writing a story of all of mankind). He does give good definitions about the things he doesn’t think the kids who are reading this would know. The most interesting part so far was the description of hieroglyphics, how they work and how people figured out they work.
Not
that I think it is a terrible book, I’ve defiantly read worse, or at least
tried to, but it is not a commanding start like I thought it would be. If a teacher made me read this in
school and told me it was a Newbery winning book, I probably would be turned
off of Newbery’s for life.
Seriously, as a kid I would have never wanted to read this, unless it
was used as a text book (anything’s better than a text book). It’s not that van Loon was a bad writer
or anything, it is just hard to fathom putting in more than 3000 years worth of
history into one book, and making it for children. There is just not enough space to get into any sort of depth
of anything.
The Christ chapter (as I am calling it) was most interesting. He seems to want to make a big
statement with it, but also be objective at the same time. So the chapter is two letters. One from
an uncle to his nephew and one from the nephew back to his uncle. I don't know if these letters are real or not. Even if they are not, it is a very
good way for him to keep his opinions to himself and not have to express them. The letters are not bad, but all they
seem to do is establish the fact that Jesus (or Joshua) was alive and people
hated him.
When you get to hear Van Loon’s voice coming through the
story more, it gets more
interesting. Like when he talks
about why you need to know something, or why he likes learning about something,
etc. When he talks about this
stuff, it gets interesting, but when he goes back to straight facts, my mind
starts to wander (and wonder; why did this win the Newbery?). Again, I
digress.
When I finish the rest of the book...I will finish the post.
When I finish the rest of the book...I will finish the post.
No comments:
Post a Comment